Interview

Thandiswa Wants A New Anthem

Written by Mpho Tshikhudo
Songstress Thandiswa Mazwai talks about her album 'Ibokwe' and why she thinks South Africa needs a new anthem.

Ibokwe's a lovely album; what has been the biggest challenge making it?
I think the challenge for me doing this album was that I decided to produce it myself in the beginning and so it was really hard trying to coordinate everything with everybody and that’s probably why it took me so long because it was the first time I decided that I was going to do everything on my album. So that was the hardest thing but it wasn’t really such a bad thing. It was difficult but interesting.

‘Ingoma’, the first single, is quite evocative.
No, I decided to write a love song for the first time. I’ve never written a love song so this is probably my first love song, and, I don’t know what you mean by evocative. I mean for me I wrote about love and I put everything that I believe about love in the song. It’s about longing for love; it’s about having it and losing it. It’s about desire, you know. So it’s everything that love encompasses for me.
 
Is the song biographical somehow?
It’s definitely about my own personal experiences with love. I mean that’s also one of the reasons why the song ends the way that it does because if you listen to ‘Ingoma’ it ends abruptly. And the reason why I did that it’s because I felt that, although love can be such a beautiful kind of euphoric experience; when it ends, it can end very abruptly and it can cut.

So it’s about the pain and the joys of love. It’s all of it in that song.

But it couldn’t have been about sex or anything like that?

No, like I said, it’s about all the experiences of love. And love is also about desire, it’s about longing; so there’s a lot of that experience in it. There’s also the experience of losing love, there’s the experience of wanting love and looking for love.

So everything that love encompasses for a grownup, that’s what the song’s about. And of course love has certain sexuality to it the older you get. And I’m a grown up now; I’m 34 years old now and so my love definitely has a sexual expression too.
 
Who inspired the song?
That I don’t reveal because as a musician when I write my music I put everything that I want to reveal in the song and everything else is kept for myself. And so, as a person who listens to the song I don’t expect you to try and find out who I wrote the song for; I expect you to try and see who you want to dedicate the song for.

Are you seeing someone, though?
Yes!

What’s his name?
Nameless! Gama lakhe ngu nameless. He remains nameless.

Do you ever think about marriage, the white picket fence and what have you?

I think about it, but it’s also one of those things that haven’t been easy for me.

Have you always been vocal about love?

I’ve never written a love song before. My music has always been a lot more kind of intellectual, looking at issues of history, issues of lineage and issues of freedom and oppression. That’s what my music has been about. But I think as a human being and as a woman I ultimately have to sing about love.

Apparently you have qualms singing the national anthem as is.
The short answer is; both Die Stem and Nkosi Sikelela represent two different ideologies and my issue was that it’s antithetical having the two of them together in one anthem. It’s antithetical having to sing Nkosi Sikelela and then move on to Die Stem. And so I felt that the two could not coexist.

What are those ideologies?
Growing up- I mean I grew up in the70s and the 80’s- and singing Nkosi Sikelela Africa, the song represented the struggle for our freedom as the oppressed people of this country. We would sing Nkosi Sikelela to represent that struggle and to represent our hopes that one day we will be free. And as a young person Die Stem represented the nationalism of those who oppressed us. That’s what Die Stem represented; it represented that nationalism- the nationalism of apartheid was represented by that song.

So I felt that I couldn’t move from singing Nkosi Sikelela and then move so effortlessly into singing Die Stem. It was not effortless for me as a South African who grew up in the 70’s and in the 80’s.

Shall we just scrap Die Stem then?
I feel that the two ideologies, in my mind, clash so I would like us to create something new, and something that we can all identify with, and identify it as a song that represents our freedom. I think- as it stands - these two songs represent things that go way deep in our history for us to pretend that suddenly they represent our new unity.

Don’t we perhaps need, like, a new arrangement altogether?
Perhaps just a brand new song! Maybe Caiphus Semenya can write us a song.

I like Caiphus, he does great chord changes whenever the fancy takes him.
Yes, he’s very good. There’s a lot of great musicians in this country I’m sure we could find somebody. Or we could put a whole bunch of people together, a nice multicultural group together and create a national anthem that we can all be proud of.

Or we could simply translate Die Stem into English?

But then what happens to those people who speak that language and want their language in the national anthem? I mean I don’t know. I don’t know how we came to this point, and I don’t know how we move beyond it. I was just kind of voicing my frustrations with always being reminded of those apartheid years and that’s what the song, Die Stem, does for me; it reminds me, it takes me back, it doesn’t take me forward.

Anyway, it’s is not an anti- Afrikaans venting or an onslaught against Afrikaans but against the principle the song Die Stem represents.

People talk about the “sunset” clauses, that somehow non Caucasians were too keen on the reconciliation. Do you think that was the case with the anthem as well?
Look I don’t want to downplay the role that the fathers of our freedom have played. I think that when former president Nelson Mandela and tata u Bishop Tutu said down and negotiated this freedom they knew what they were talking about. But our responsibilities as this generation now in our time is to make sure  that as we move ahead in history, we are able to hold on to our dignity and hold on to things that are important  to our history ,and we are able to truly build  the South Africa that will be for  all.

My idea of a better national anthem is…
A national anthem that doesn’t have spaces where some people sit down and some people stand up and some people stop singing and some people don’t, you know; it’s a national anthem that we can all sing with pride and hold each other’s hands and reach out and touch and wave our hands in the air and be this rainbow nation. But at the moment I know that people do not sing the whole national anthem.

57 Thoughts
SPEAK YOUR MIND
  1. I really fail to undertsand why people do not unerstand what Thandiswa was saying. She was asked a question and she gave HER opinion. In south africa we all - black and white tend to react emotionally and not debate. I think it is high time we all admitted that the rainbow was a lie and get on with the real task of nation building and to do so we will need to have debates like this and constructive comments are needed. I also find it funny how people will say we should move on but the next thing they say reflects that they are very much stuck in the past. We all were victims of apartheid- black and white. By the way Thandiswa is an incredible talent and in her new album she talks about crime, rape, the lies of our leaders, so all of you who are quick to jump down her throat should actually listen to her album.
    By Tshenolo Sebolai
    Posted 11 months ago
  2. ahem... so has anyone listened to Thandiswa Mazwai's ulbum yet? or maybe even the song being discussed in the piece "ingoma"
    By that one
    Posted 11 months ago
  3. I am reading about black people whom cant move on. Ek is 'n Afrikaans sprekende wat ook dink die stem moet voertsek! We can only have Nkosi alone. But I guess the Afrikaners will be singing Die Stem each December the 16th. No I do wonder who cant move on? Until Jesus comes!
    By Recato Eberwein
    Posted 11 months ago
  4. There is no racism in South Africa, there are only white people who are anti-black. None of the people who took offence to Thandiswa's opinion really paid attention to the fact that she said both Nkosi Sikelela and De Stem are not suitable as an anthem going forward. They simply jumped to a conclusion and swore at her. Even those that started the comment with ' please dont blame everything on apartheid' went ahead and said their beautiful country is run by criminals. Inference, that anything black is criminal. Well the truth is white people are not patriotic and they hate black people if you dont believe me , read your comments in all news peices and blogs.
    By KReal
    Posted 11 months ago
  5. Hi Molefe wanna compete intelectually we can do that any time. Maybe my son will do as a first year student being a victim in sport and academically with thing like bursaries. He is doing good maths also, eat your heart out. Wanna take him on else, me, build many things for u people. Grew up from a father with no education cause of British, no regret. Learn from this the boere are very honest maybe naive believing people like de klerk. But watch out a new generation of youths are on U. People like me can go anyware cause we can and are in demand. u can get there as well by blaming youreselves and do something about it rather than trying to blame the poor boers for there Anthem and heritage. Get of your pedestal and proof me wrong.
    By georgie
    Posted 11 months ago
  6. i dont see anything wrong with thandiswa expressing her opinion which does make sense. i guesse there's no point raising a sober remark full of COFFIN DODGERS (u know who u r). this subject will remain ahead of our era as long as dont have the sufficient interlectual capacity and emotional interligence to debate it. im about to throw the towel on this country. will things really change mara?
    By molefi
    Posted 11 months ago
  7. Yes, I agree with that women? replace the anthem with Bok's " De La Rey" Chris van die Kaap: As dit nie vir die dom Afrikaners was nie sou jy in elk geval nie eers hier kon skryf nie. Los uit die dom Afrikaners want jy jou lewe aan te danke het.
    By Stef
    Posted 11 months ago
  8. So you want the STEM to go ?? And this would really sort out how many problems ?? The problem with POST COLONIALISTS like we have here is that they do not appreciate the skill of the white man. He caused apartheid but heck that is the only reason SA is still in the relatively good (by AFRICAN standards) shape it is in. If I were a black person in this country in 2009 I would be asking : OK so what have we built for our brothers and sisters in the past 15 yrs ?? Where are the schools, the houses, the hospitals the community centres etc etc....... ??? I would not be worrying about changing names of past grievances. Look back far enough and the Colonialists themselves were slaves. Please ask our sister how highly she regards the North African drug lords who can only get into SA cause we have lost apartheid.
    By LUMP OF COAL
    Posted 11 months ago
  9. Ok laat die stem gaan. Op een voorwaarde ons verf nie ons gesigte nie. Geen BEE almal gelyk no afirmative action. Net mense met at least matriek kan stem. Geen uitlanders. Party mense verstaan nie hulle is in die meerderheid daar is geen demokrasie nie. Hulle betaal skaars belasting en dan bemoei hulle hulle met die volkslied wat in elk geval klakkeloos is. Nkosi is aangegryp by gebrek aan iniatief. Duidelik is ons anders. Whoever this singer is never heard of her anyway. Maybe she must concentrate on songs against crime corruption etc.
    By georgie
    Posted 11 months ago
  10. So "The Stem" must go right? She does not have respect for a certain race group that cherish that part of our anthem. So since she may be disrespectful, let it be my turn. Who must take her serious? Look at her picture. Looks like something that crawl from under the kraal. Sad we have to be like this, could she not respect my heritage and I hers. No we can't and we never will. It is Africa. It knows no respect.
    By Vark
    Posted 11 months ago
  11. kom net by asseblief die stem SAL in die volkslied bly.Wat se die woord volkslied "VOLKS" almal is deel van die volk en almal moet mos "gelyke regte hê"so vat vir jou.
    By anon
    Posted 11 months ago
  12. I have worked and lived in 28 countries with all sorts of people, and I believe the only answer to the Anthem question is a symbolic piece of music, no words, just stand in silence and say a prayer for the day.maybe hold hands with the person nearest. that is all. Short and peaceful.
    By Chris Harrison-Smith
    Posted 11 months ago
  13. Helpful discussion, unlike most of this thread: http://bit.ly/4tXmcm
    By Sneaker
    Posted 11 months ago
  14. Sal iemand my asb help om 'n nuwe Afrikaner volk te stig. Een wat sy taal sal praat en nie besmet met al wat 'n Engelse woord is nie - een wat nie brandy en coke drink, ballas karp en winde opbreuk nie. Een wat 'n Afrikaans sprekende Suid Afrikaner is em homself distansieer van alles wat die huidige Afrikaners voorstaan. Dan sal die nuwe Volkslied behoorlik gesing word - met trots deur ons almal in SA!!!
    By Rudi Botha
    Posted 11 months ago
  15. Ag no Sussie, I just spent days to learn our National Anthem in all the 5 languages by heart and now you want to destroy it. Not fair. I now also started learning Zulu at my tender age of 63 and I understand each sentence of our Anthem . I think it is more a very apt prayer than an anthem. I also think the few Afrikaans sentences are very meaningful and extremely descriptive of our grand country. let us rather destroy poverty, then crime before we worry about the Stem and Joost Van Der Westhuizen
    By Chris S
    Posted 11 months ago
  16. L.I.F.O. Last in first out.
    By Delia
    Posted 11 months ago
  17. Apartheid is in the past!!! Yes, I know it might be easy for me to say. But why not look to the future instead of living in the past. We cannot progress if that is the case. I am 42 and never knew Apartheid existed. I played with black kids, grew up with them and some were my best friends, so DO NOT generalise all whites. As far as I have experienced and witnessed. The blacks in this country are even more racist than the whites of today. There seems to still be Apartheid in this country, except that it is now in reverse and has been given another name. Shame on you. Must the whites now lose their heritage and history because you did not agree with some of the policies of the PAST. Live for now and the future, otherwise you will get nowhere.
    By L Green
    Posted 11 months ago
  18. A lot of comment since I posted mine. I am ashamed to see the poor language use. Moslty from Afrikaans men. Manne - klim uit julle grotte uit en hou op om julle self so op te sweep. Hou op om die brandy-n-coke taal van jou parties hier te gebruik. Julle geskel en gevloek hel niks. Dit bly maar net 'n geskel en gevloek. En wys hou agterlik jull eientlik is. Net soos jou 3 liter Ford Coritina met die geel furr op die dash.
    By Steve
    Posted 11 months ago
  19. It has been 15 years, and yet apartheid is still used for everything. How old is thandiswa? I am 27 years old and was 12 when apartheid was banned. I had like her, nothing to do with apartheid. We were also poor, poorer than some of the blacks who is now previously disadvantaged ,but studied at overseas universities. Lets leave apartheid alone. Otherwise no one in this country will be able to move on. I guess if everybody in high positions, Malema, Chuenne can blame apartheid for everything and threaten with war everytime things dont go their way, we cant expect anyone else to forget it. If you want to be a leader, how about leading the way into the future, by not making a pitstop in the past
    By Natasha
    Posted 11 months ago
  20. You know I have read the comments people have made about this issue. It is so diverse and it just shows how differently people think in this country about different issues. Putting your point across without hurting the other person is a way forward. You can debate this issue but there will always be someone that will not be pleased with the outcome. Thandiswe was asked a question and she answered it as truthfully as she could so she should not be dissed for that. Its her personal answer. Be tolerant people and give the other person a chance to give their views without insulting or shooting them down.
    By Verni
    Posted 11 months ago
  21. Ek hou niks van die saamgeflanste volkslied nie. Die Departement van Kuns en Kultuur kan gerus n kompetisie uitskryf vir n nuwe volkslied.
    By Selma
    Posted 11 months ago
  22. Everyting white must go mustn't it, you fucking cunt. Typical everything before 1994 = BAD and everything after1994 = GOOD attitude. Come rigfht out for once and admit your contempt and hatred for whites and their heritage in this country (or continent). Blow me
    By J Bekker
    Posted 11 months ago
  23. Going by the emotive debate on this issue it is clear that we need a new neutral anthem that we can all relate to. As ek kyk hoe die "Boere" Nkosi Sikelela sing by die rugby kry ek die indruk dat, die meerderheid in elk geval, nie omgee om die huidige volkslied te sing nie.
    By Boy in George
    Posted 11 months ago
  24. Here we go again. Let us just cling to what happenened in the past and blame everything on apartheid. And some of you guys are right, I am not a white south african, but at least in those years I had more freedon. Now I am too afraid to even open my doors or enjoy my garden or go out and not be afraid. I am afraid that with all the corruption going on we may not have a country that we can be proud of in a couple of years. So my dear "Thandiswa" go ahead and write a new Anthem, BUT PLEASE MAKE SURE THAT YOU WRITE ABOUT MURDER, RAPE, RAPIST AND MURDERS RIGHTS, THE POOR VICTIMS THAT HAVE NO RIGHTS, THE CORRUPTION IN THE THE PEOPLE RUNNING OUR COUNTRY AND THE FEAR THAT WE ARE ALL FACED WITH. PLEASE MAKE SURE THAT ALL THAT IS INCLUDED, OTHERWISE PLEASE JUST LEAVE THINGS AS IT IS, THE TAX-PAYERS MONEY IS WASTED ON ENOUGHT CRAP.
    By Natasha
    Posted 11 months ago
  25. Very painful subject on both sides. But aren't we ridiculous..in yesteryear when there was no debate about it, I hated singing Die Stem mainly because it bored me. Now it embarrases me because it has become an idol. Let's sing a new song.
    By PHYLLIS
    Posted 11 months ago
  26. Aan al die dom Afrikaners wat hier reageer.Eerstens, leer om te spel en probeer tog om julle woordeskat te vergroot.Julle reaksie is so tipies van die eng, verkrampte Afrikaner wat nog in die verlede wil leef.
    By Chris Kaapstad
    Posted 11 months ago
  27. If it aint broke dont fix it. She needs to stfu. And I agree with alot of what Suzette said. well said Eugene, and "lol.. +1" to Willempie
    By Nish
    Posted 11 months ago
  28. Ja asseblief, gee ons n nuwe volkslied in Engels. Dis tyd om aan te beweeg en te vergeet van die "struggle" en apartheid. Ons word hieraan herinner in die aangeflaanste volkslied wat ons nou het. Afrikaners, waarvan ek een is, moet besef n kompromie is nodig, en die "comrades" moet nou maar hul wapens neerle en die "struggle songs" laat gaan.
    By Pieter
    Posted 11 months ago
  29. The bottom line is that the anthem should be scrapped in its entirity and replaced with something in English only. No advantage to blacks who blame apartheid for everything, nor for Afrikaaners who are racist to the core and will NEVER accept that we have moved on.
    By Brian
    Posted 11 months ago
  30. Lets just let things be .we have much bigger issues to dealwith.I dont think she thought about this logistically as to how much all those changes could cost the taxpayer.its bad enough that we have to deal with uncessary namechanges.let sleeping dogs lie.
    By Ivy
    Posted 11 months ago
  31. Alles in aggenome, die "crime" en omgekeerder rassisme, ens, is ek 'n trotse Afrikaanse Suid Afrikaner. Dis tog jammer om te sien dat slegs die Afrikaanse kommentaar sulke kru taal en snedige opmerkings bevat! Laat mens maar wonder oor die karakter en agtergrond van sommiges ne Johan Du Plessis, Willempie en Mark. Julle hoort tussen die "bobbejane in die berge"
    By NUWE SUID AFRIKANER
    Posted 11 months ago
  32. How about: Mudzimu fhatutshedza lushaka lwa hashu. U pfe dzi thabelo dzashu, murena. Will all the Zulus and Xhosas like the sound of that as a national anthem. I love you dearly Thandiswa, but get off this issue. Lets fights marijuana and alcohol abuse and you see this country shaping up to become the best in the country. Luv ya
    By Terry The Terrible
    Posted 11 months ago
  33. She should not use white cream on her face. They know by now that any thing white is not good for them. The back cream is much better except for it doesn't do the job. Also a lot of rubbish Nê !!
    By coen
    Posted 11 months ago
  34. Is it so impossible for white south africans to enter into a constructive debate without becoming personal and insulting. Thandiswa was asked a question and she gave her personal opinion - what is wrong with that? I'm a Afrikaans speaking white male and I think that she is probably right - both Nkosi and Die Stem are beautiful songs but not all understand Xhosa and Afrikaans which creates a problem when singing the anthem. Some black and white people have issues with the two songs which could be eliminated with a new anthem. On the other side - the 3 languages reflects the diversity of the nation which is nice. I personally would not mind a new English anthem for SA. And to Mark - you need serious councilling Boet!
    By Jaco
    Posted 11 months ago
  35. Thandiswa I applaud you ! I absolutely agree with your opinion regarding the National Anthem A few writers and singers, a multicultural group, should come up with a few songs. The group should then sing about four of these songs on national TV. Maybe the country can send in their votes, perhaps have a prize ! Just ideas. My daughter has an abreviation of your name, her second name is Thandi. Actually I can tell you a quite a story about the struggle we had when we adopted her before Nelson Mandela was released. We had to fight all the colours in this rainbow nation as well as the Wellfare Organizations representative who believe it or not was black ! This was before anyone had adopted across the colour bar. Now she has a South African mother, an Irish father ! and she is Xhosa. She is studying Architecture and we are so proud of her Esmé McFarland
    By Esmé McFarland
    Posted 11 months ago
  36. I wish that the South African population would once and for all put RASICM behind them. They carry on about the apartheid era but they are the biggest culprits! The whites must forget and sit back and see how this country that was beautiful and perfect, now be destroyed by the criminals of the current ruling party. Where is the freedom now that you cannot even (and that is black and white) walk on the streets or anywhere and get mugged or shot or raped. STOP advocating such nonsense as you and others are doing and do something constructive and meaningful. Let sleeping dogs lie and don't start another "struggle".
    By Suzette
    Posted 11 months ago
  37. Thandiswa....you realy sing a lot of crap.Get married and become a house-wife. But...I agree we do need a new National Anthem...a shorter one...and please in ENGLISH...so that every educated person in this country can understand it and then sing it.
    By Nouveau
    Posted 11 months ago
  38. I CANT UNDERSTAND WHY BLACK PEOPLE CANT MOVE FORWARD AND WANT TO DESTROY ANYTHING THAT IS NOT FROM THEIR CULTURE.WE ARE ALL SOUTH AFRICANS AND OUR DIVERSITY SHOULD BE CLEAR IN THE ANTHEM. MORE WHITES ARE KILLED IN THEIR HOMES TODAY THAN PEOPLES WERE EVER KILLED DURING APARTHEID. MAYBE BLACKS WILL BE HAPPY WEN OUR NEW ANTHEM WILL BE CALLED ONE SETTLER ONE BULLET ORE BRING MY MACHINE GUN?
    By HANNES
    Posted 11 months ago
  39. Dis eintlik nie eens die moeite werd om de moer in te raak nie! Thandiswa lyk soos iets wat uit n "District 9" shack uitgekruip het - so ek dink sy het groter probleme as om oor Die Stem te worry!
    By Mark
    Posted 11 months ago
  40. English must go and those who still favour English imperialism. Nkosi must go -it's a black power anthem and its synonomous with "kill the farmer, kill the boer"-everything from the so-called struggle. If they ban die Stem and it falls away from the medley-there will still be people who sing it- as a freedom song. The new SA flag and Nkosi is a symbol of oppression by black on white. Mandela lied when he said he fought against oppression of either race, because that is impossible in Africa.
    By Awie
    Posted 11 months ago
  41. At thy call we shall not falter, firm and steadfast we shall stand. At thy will to live or perish, oh South Africa, our land. (part of Die Stem in English) Ek dink as n mens lief is vir jou land, dan is dit nie a politieke standpunt nie. Nie alles van die slegte ou dae was sleg nie. Ek was toe, en is nog steeds, lief vir my land.
    By Collin
    Posted 11 months ago
  42. Hoe are you and what are you? Please leave apartheid alone this is just a excuse for all the crime in our country. Now you want to change the anthem- Open your eyes- there very serious issues in this country- rather use this money to feed the poor and staving people NOW THAT WOULD BE A CHANGE FOR THE GOOD and not some stupid idea because you still live in the apartheid sindrom
    By Alta
    Posted 11 months ago
  43. As sy sleg voel om Die Stem te sing moet sy haarself indink hoe dit vir ons voel om n Kommunistiese lied te sing waarteen ons Galonnne bloed verloor het. Ek is doodgellukig om net die stem te sing sy kan haar Nkosi vat en in haar gat op druk.
    By Johann du Plessis
    Posted 11 months ago
  44. i think our national antem should change. as we are a country of eleven languages so we should involve all the languages. Thandiswa you've just opened our eyes girl
    By Sindy
    Posted 11 months ago
  45. Both must go and be replaced by an ENGLISH anthem, i never sang die stem and I certainly don't sing Nkosi. Also scrap the other 10 languages and have only English as the official language.
    By Avril
    Posted 11 months ago
  46. I fully agree with Thandiswa's sentiments, she is very brave to actually open up this debate. South Africans have a tendency of shoving things under the carpets, we like to pretend that all is well. I get so ashamed of our loooong National Anthem, understandably due to our nature of trying to please everyone, but as you have said, some of us dont sing the whole National Anthem due to our painful past and the symbolysim that the two songs have. We trully need a song that can be composed by all the South African musicians (Black & White), a song that speaks of our pride, our heritage, how strong our country is, a song that speaks to all of us. One thing though, it must be short & to the point.
    By Ben
    Posted 11 months ago
  47. My taal is net so belangrik vir my as jou taal is vir jou. Nou, na 15 jaar, raak ek net so bewoe as ek die volkslied sing/hoor as wat ek was toe ek 'n kind was. Daar was toe, en is nou ook, vir my absoluut geen prolitiese konnotasie nie. Ek sing die hele volkslied, met my swak uitspreking van woorde wat ek nie ken nie en al! Waarom kan ons tog nie die verlede opsyskuif en werk aan die toekoms nie!! Dit is tog wat Madiba ook wou he.
    By Bets
    Posted 11 months ago
  48. Lets get comrade Mugabe here!!no need to discuss anything cause we end up no-where,we need him to come an implement all the policies that will favour the previously disadvantaged,otherwise we keep on giving mr bobejaan klim die berg an opportunity to feel like they own the country and continue with arrogance. anyway Mr Malema will get his day and all shall inherit the riches of the country.
    By koffs
    Posted 11 months ago
  49. I think it is time we start moving away from all this apartheid issues. We have been in a democracy for 15 years and still apartheid is blamed for today's problems. There is always talk about the struggle of the opressed, but those same people do not think of all the South Africans who are murdered every day and it is not just the older generation but even young teenagers who are murdered. Stop blaming apartheid and think of all the new wounds that are being created every day. We need to heal our nation, not create new wounds. I think once we can move forward without creating all these new wounds, once we have a safe country to live in, we can look at other issues like an anthem.
    By Joey
    Posted 11 months ago
  50. Wat n pot kak! "Anyway, it’s is not an anti- Afrikaans venting or an onslaught against Afrikaans but against the principle the song Die Stem represents." Jy weet nie waarvan jy praat nie, so hou jouself maar eerder by die kak musiek wat jy self maak! Jy probeer jou rassisme wegsteek, maar jy flous net jouself!
    By Mark
    Posted 11 months ago
  51. In a way I share her sentiment. The difference is that Nkosi is now the song of the corrupt and oppressors. Think about Malema, weapons scandal, the shaik family, rape cases, etc. etc. Nkosi is a prayer of hope and no longer belongs in this corrupt country of ours where criminals have more rights than citizens. And Willimpie - your attitude is really not contributing anything. You remained behind in the apartheid era.
    By Steve
    Posted 11 months ago
  52. Yes! The woman with the funny makeup is right. Let's make it "Bobbejaan klim die berg" translated into eleven languages...
    By Willempie
    Posted 11 months ago
  53. Not a good time to change the number plate when the wheels are falling off the car.
    By Gruntfuttock
    Posted 11 months ago
  54. Yes, I think Madiba set the example of our attitudes towards each other.
    By Tess
    Posted 11 months ago
  55. Yes, the anthem must go, in totality, and be replaced by something new. It must be possible to come up with something that could be sung, simultaneously, with English, Zulu and Xhosa words. You sing the song using the language you are comfortable with. If necessary have an anthem without words. there is at least one country which has such an anthem.
    By Piet
    Posted 11 months ago
  56. As to the last comment. Has she thought that not everyone can speak an African languge. and different people sing the parts they know, what's wrong with that. That's where I think Madiba was wise in his Nation building, by giving everyone a chance.
    By daz
    Posted 11 months ago
  57. If you really want problems open this issue again. Leave well enough alone even if the entire issue has become bastardised by the commercial usage We have a lot more serious issues to attend to than creating others--you forget that there are those that object to the Christiaan connotation in this diversified country to Nkosi Sekelele We have enough wounds do not open Pandoras box
    By Eugene Viljoen Snr
    Posted 11 months ago

Post a Comment

Your email address will never be displayed